
A letter sent on Thursday to the leadership of the Estonian National Opera alleges that the institution is systematically excluding Estonian soloists who have built international careers from performing at home. The accusation, made public by sopranos Aile Asszonyi and Monika-Evelin Liiv, claims that the theatre is “pushing away” top Estonian talent who have succeeded abroad, leaving the stage to local artists with less international exposure. “Right now, Estonia’s National Opera is not burning as an artistic torch in Estonia’s music world,” Asszonyi told Vikerraadio on Thursday. “It is sputtering amid another round of scandals.”
The letter, which ERR reported on Thursday, names Liiv among its authors and quotes her as saying that Estonian singers who have reached world stages feel “locked out” of their home theatre. Asszonyi, who is currently performing in Japan, told Vikerhommik on Thursday that the situation is “absurd.” Both singers insist the dispute is not about money but about artistic opportunity and national pride.
The controversy comes as Estonia’s cultural sector faces broader scrutiny over leadership and artistic direction. In a separate interview with Eesti Ekspress on Thursday, Liiv said the theatre’s current policies are forcing top Estonian voices to seek stages abroad, undermining the country’s reputation in classical music. “We all want to come home to sing,” she said, “but the door feels closed.”
The Estonian National Opera has not publicly responded to the allegations. The theatre’s leadership has previously defended casting decisions as based on artistic merit and production needs, but no statement has been issued since the letter’s publication on Thursday.
The timing of the accusation coincides with a period of heightened public debate over national cultural institutions. Asszonyi, who has performed at La Scala, the Metropolitan Opera and other major venues, told Vikerraadio on Thursday that the current leadership’s approach risks turning Estonia’s flagship opera house into a provincial venue rather than a beacon of artistic excellence. “We don’t need a theatre that trembles at every new idea,” she said. “We need one that ignites them.”
Follow us for live European news
1 further source not geolocated