The French Senate gave final approval on Friday to a law presuming police officers who use firearms acted lawfully, passing the measure 205 votes to 110. [1]

The upper house of parliament approved the text on Friday after the lower house passed it on July 7. [2] The law stipulates that "when they use their weapons", police officers "are presumed to have acted" within the framework of the law. [1] It does not expand the situations in which officers may use firearms. It shifts the burden of proof. The presumption can be rebutted only if victims, their families or prosecutors present evidence to the contrary. [2]

Backers including the government, centrists, The Republicans and the far-right Rassemblement National of presidential candidate Marine Le Pen say the law prevents officers from being automatically suspected of disproportionate force. [1] Interior Minister Laurent Nuñez said on Thursday it would "put an end to the automatic practice of taking into custody a police officer or gendarme who has used their weapon." [1] He said it would "correct this reflex of systematically calling into question the daily, highly demanding work of our security forces." [1] Conservative senator Lauriane Josende of The Republicans said the aim was to provide law enforcement with legal protection tailored to the specific conditions in which they intervene. [3]

Left-wing lawmakers, rights organizations and unions oppose the measure, warning it will lead to more killings and make it harder for victims' families to seek justice. [3] Critics have dubbed it a "licence to kill." [1] France's Human Rights League argued it would "block the opening of an investigation" into police shootings following a failure to comply with a traffic stop or during crowd control. [1] The left has pledged to appeal to the Constitutional Council, the country's highest constitutional authority. [4] UN special rapporteur on extrajudicial executions Morris Tidball-Binz wrote to French authorities that "it should not fall on victims and their families to find the necessary elements to eliminate an initial presumption of lawfulness." [3] He noted this is especially problematic when authorities control key evidence. [3]

Student-led protests in recent weeks have focused on police brutality. [1] Young men "perceived as Arab, Black or from North Africa" are four times more likely to be stopped than the rest of the population, according to a report last year by France's rights chief. [1] The killing of 17-year-old Nahel Merzouk in 2023 sparked nationwide riots. [3] Opponents note that French security forces are already the most lethal in Europe. [5]

Activist Samia El Khalfaoui, whose nephew Souheil was killed by a police officer in 2021, protested outside the Senate on Thursday. [3] "The quest for truth will become even more impossible," she said. [3] Unions and youth organizations have called protests for Saturday, and Nuñez warned prefects that demonstrations could bring additional tensions. [2]